The VAR delay before Manchester City's Semenyo goal was a controversial moment in the Carabao Cup win at Newcastle. The semi-automated offside technology (SAOT) failed to detect the offside, resulting in a five-minute delay. The incident sparked criticism from City manager Pep Guardiola, who questioned the inconsistencies of VAR. The delay was due to the packed box, which meant officials had to revert to the old system of drawing crosshairs. This 'edge case' scenario highlights the challenges of implementing technology in football. The controversy extends to the non-award of penalties to City in the same match, with the KMI panel suggesting a penalty should have been given for a challenge on Phil Foden. The PGMOL's chief refereeing officer, Howard Webb, has been invited to explain the decision regarding the Haaland goal, but there has been no immediate response. This incident raises questions about the reliability of technology in football and the need for clear communication between officials and clubs.
